|
Who said economics is about forecasting the future
Who said economics is about forecasting the future
Gideon Rachman of the FT wants to dethrone economists. I am all for it, but what grates in his article is the view that economics as a science is defined by its ability to forecast the future. No, it is not, and whoever said that is not very knowledgeable about economics as a discipline.
Well, except that Rachman takes his definition from … Joe Stiglitz!
I am sure Stiglitz would recant, or at least argue that his comment was taken out of context, upon close examination. At best, economics can help us make contingent predictions -- a long way off from forecasting.
There is plenty wrong with the way that economists have behaved in the run-up to the financial crisis without ascribing such grandiose claims to economics.
My take is that you should blame economists, not economics:
The problem is that economists (and those who listen to them) became over-confident in their preferred models of the moment: markets are efficient, financial innovation transfers risk to those best able to bear it, self-regulation works best, and government intervention is ineffective and harmful.
They forgot that there were many other models that led in radically different directions. Hubris creates blind spots. If anything needs fixing, it is the sociology of the profession. The textbooks -- at least those used in advanced courses -- are fine.
Non-economists tend to think of economics as a discipline that idolizes markets and a narrow concept of (allocative) efficiency. If the only economics course you take is the typical introductory survey,newisabelmarantoutlet.webs.com, or if you are a journalist asking an economist for a quick opinion on a policy issue, that is indeed what you will encounter. But take a few more economics courses, or spend some time in advanced seminar rooms, and you will get a different picture.
Labor economists focus not only on how trade unions can distort markets, but also how, under certain conditions, they can enhance productivity. Trade economists study the implications of globalization on inequality within and across countries. Finance theorists have written reams on the consequences of the failure of the "efficient markets" hypothesis. Open-economy macroeconomists examine the instabilities of international finance. Advanced training in economics requires learning about market failures in detail, and about the myriad ways in which governments can help markets work better.
Macroeconomics may be the only applied field within economics in which more training puts greater distance between the specialist and the real world, owing to its reliance on highly unrealistic models that sacrifice relevance to technical rigor. Sadly, in view of today's needs,cheapisabelmarantclub.webs.com, macroeconomists have made little progress on policy since John Maynard Keynes explained how economies could get stuck in unemployment due to deficient aggregate demand. Some, like Brad DeLong and Paul Krugman, would say that the field has actually regressed.
Economics is really a toolkit with multiple models - each a different, stylized representation of some aspect of reality. One's skill as an economist depends on the ability to pick and choose the right model for the situation.
Economics' richness has not been reflected in public debate because economists have taken far too much license. Instead of presenting menus of options and listing the relevant trade-offs - which is what economics is about - economists have too often conveyed their own social and political preferences. Instead of being analysts, they have been ideologues, favoring one set of social arrangements over others.
Furthermore, economists have been reluctant to share their intellectual doubts with the public, lest they "empower the barbarians." No economist can be entirely sure that his preferred model is correct. But when he and others advocate it to the exclusion of alternatives, they end up communicating a vastly exaggerated degree of confidence about what course of action is required.
I agree but it will not stop Mr. Rodrik (or other economists) from accepting the Nobel Memorial Prize in Economic Sciences. I am not sure why the term is needed. In any case, there is already a prize for literature.
Science, as I understand it, involves both explanation and prediction. At best economics provides ex-post explanations and even here there is very little agreement.
With reference to the comment on history by Bendien, it is convenient to divorce history from economics. Conveniently,Isabel Marant Sneakers, there were no politics in the creation of the system.
"Non-economists tend to think of economics as a discipline that idolizes markets and a narrow concept of (allocative) efficiency. If the only economics course you take is the typical introductory survey, or if you are a journalist asking an economist for a quick opinion on a policy issue, that is indeed what you will encounter."
Well, that is a serious problem with economics as a science. An introductory course, or a quick answer from a practiser, shouldn be that flawed. If it couldn whow you the whole picture,buyisabelmarantoutlet.webs.com, it should at least tell you it wasn the whole picture.
The first stage Wedding Dresses of spring wedding will give you so many things to plan and organize. Taking some time first to think and jot down some initial wedding ideas or Evening Gowns themes is really important before referring to any wedding vendors or Evening Dresses
venues. Having your wedding in this beautiful season can bestow a marriage life full of excitement and adventure.
The first stage Wedding Dresses of spring wedding will give you so many things to plan and organize,Cheap Isabel Marant Sneakers. Taking some time first to think and jot down some initial wedding ideas or Evening Gowns themes is really important before referring to any wedding vendors or Evening Dresses
venues. You can look your article comments. This information has really been helpful for most of the readers. I really appreciate the way you have written about this. I will really like to read more on this from you. I know your expertise on this. I must say we should have an online discussion on this. The league officials have also supported the call, but still a defence against Coleman is being men moncler coats made on Twitter as many feel the tackle was a clean and legal one. Ryan Clark from the Steelers is also one of them who are supporting Coleman. Football moncler men jackets is considered to be a violent game and so such tackles should not be overruled from the game which has made the game so moncler jacket outlet popular in the country. With help of multilayers inside design from cheap coach wallets outlet for sale, you can collect different kinds of cards and put money inside that you want to. I sure you find what you want among the great amount of clearance coach purses on sale here. Welcome to coach online store and buy them now. With help of multilayers inside design from cheap coach wallets outlet for sale, you can collect different kinds of cards and put money inside that you want to. I sure you find what you want among the great amount of clearance coach purses on sale here. Welcome to coach online store and buy them now. Enjoy the fashion world now.
French unions 23 launched a nationwide strike in the second month, Moncler jackets 290 million people took to the streets to protest against the government intends to push the retirement system reform. Because of air moncler coats transport operators are also involved in Paris Charles DE gaulle airport, moncler sale estimation and ollie airport yesterday 40% and 50% of the flights are cancelled, other airport also can maintain 60% flights. Moncler Union estimated 2.5 million in December 7, is expected to strike the number 23 strike than last time, France has a protest rally, traffic 231, more than half the train service, Moncler jackets sale but the connection of Britain and France eurostar service, maintain the normal. The BBC reports, the big strike over to Paris public transportation. Paris metro line, there are 16 during the morning go to work in the 23rd, Moncler jackets Men Paris metro only five runs normally. From the game, inter are not a real sense of team. It is udinese performed very well in the match, the winner of the grand slam season, to make a lot of trouble, let the nerazzurri defence under moncler coats test. Udinese's biggest mistake is not to grasp the opportunities created itself. Regardless of how the game, because it was the first home game of the season, the inter fans to Spanish benitez says a maximum support. The huge banners north bank is Spanish. Japan's Supreme Court decision to confirm the higher court sendai 10th January 1991 regarding visits to the yasukuni shrine violates the constitution. moncler sale High court of rock sendai hand county residents of the yasukuni shrine litigation trial. Moncler jackets sale The trial, the higher court that sendai formal visits to the outlet moncler shrine on purpose in religious significance, should say with particular religious care to arouse the behavior, Moncler jackets Men belong to the con-stitution forbids religious behavior. moncler jackets women Carlo ancelotti has confirmed, terry told me he had outlet moncler problems, hope can be ruled out. I take the anelka was suspended for drogba, so he will play on Wednesday. moncler jackets women black We hope that John terry and frank lampard could even pay, but I think they must be able to train well before. |
|